Making A Profit In Construction
by: Michael C. Stone
How do you make a profit in construction? If you follow the
thinking of many, it is all in how you build your jobs. That has
been the focus of national construction related magazines and
conventions for years. If getting better at production is the
way to make money, why then do construction businesses have such
a high failure rate?
Getting better at production is not the
answer to financial success. It is charging more for the work
you do and it is just that simple. Most contractors do not
charge enough for the work they do. That includes new
homebuilders, remodelers or specialty contractors.
When I do seminars and classes on MARKUP, I ask the following
question. “You should never try to be competitive, you should
always try to be _____?” The answer, of course, is profitable.
You must make a profit if you wish to remain in business. If
you do not make a profit, you and your business will go away.
Then you will have the task of trying to pay off a pile of
bills. That statement presumes you would do the honorable thing
and repay your debts and not declare bankruptcy.
Either case is far more work and heartache than learning the
basics of how to establish the correct sales price for your
work. Once learned, you can put those basics into action, and
become one of the few that ever makes more than a living in this
business.
First, let’s define MARKUP. MARKUP is a number that,
multiplied times the job cost, will yield a sales price that
will cover all job costs, overhead expenses and profit.
The very first thing that you need to know is your overhead
expenses for the last year, or what you project them to be for
the next year. That number should include both fixed and
variable overhead. Then you need to convert that expense to a
percentage of the total work done while incurring those
expenses.
Here are some percentages for contractors that are doing
under 2.5 million dollars in volume a year. Remodeling
contractors will typically have overhead expenses ranging from
about 24% to 42%, or even higher, with the average being about
28% - 32%. New home contractors will have a range of about 12%
to 28% with an average being about 18% - 22%. Specialty
contractors that do just one trade will normally have overhead
expenses similar to remodeling contractors but slightly less.
You will note the large difference in the overhead expense
percentage between the new homebuilder and the remodeling
contractor. That difference is why general contractors doing new
home construction must use a different markup than those doing
remodeling work. That is the main reason that you should not try
to do both. Few general contractors have the discipline to use
two separate MARKUPS, one for new homes and one for remodeling
as their numbers will dictate. They make the mistake of using
the smaller MARKUP thinking it should cover them for all jobs.
It won’t, in fact can’t. When you’re done with this column, you
will know how to do the math to prove that statement to
yourself.
Once you have your overhead expense established, you need to
set a goal for profit. Your goal should be no less than 8%, and
preferably 10% or more.
We need two more numbers to arrive at the correct selling
price for your work. The first number is the volume of work for
the same period of 12 months. If you have been in business more
than three years, you should be able to predict that number very
closely. If you’re still new, you will have to make an educated
guess.
Let’s assume that we have $250,000 in sales. Looking at a
remodeling company first, if we assume $250,000 in sales and 30%
overhead, we have an expected overhead expense of $75,000. An 8%
profit would be $20,000. To compute our job costs, we subtract
overhead and profit from total sales and get $155,000 ($250,000
- $75,000 - $20,000 = $155,000). $155,000 is our job costs, or
the money we have to build the job(s) sold. The formula to
arrive at the correct MARKUP for our company is:
SALES PRICE ÷ JOB COSTS = MARKUP
$250,000 ÷ $155,000 = 1.6129 or 1.62
Now let’s do the markup for a company building
new homes. If we assume a total of $250,000 in sales, and we
have 18% overhead, that means an expected overhead expense of
$45,000. 8% profit is $20,000. Now to get job costs, subtract
overhead and profit from total sales and get $185,000 ($250,000
- $45,000 - $20,000 = $185,500). $185,000 is our job costs. The
formula to arrive at the correct MARKUP for our company is:
SALES PRICE ÷ JOB COSTS = MARKUP
$250,000 ÷ $185,000 = 1.3514 or 1.36
I can hear the screams of anguish and disbelief
from all quarters. “Nobody can use that MARKUP and sell a job in
this town. I can’t use more than a 10% MARKUP, that’s all I can
get.”
OK, show me where the math is wrong. That is first. The math is
correct, regardless of how many times you run it out on your
calculator. More importantly however, you now see why so many
companies go broke in this business. This is why I said above,
“most contractors do not charge enough for the work that they
do.” If you think that you can’t use the markup numbers that we
have calculated here, you are in all probability undercharging
your own customers for your work.
Second, remember this is a hypothetical case
showing the correct math formula to arrive at the correct sales
price for your work. If you do remodeling work, your MARKUP may
only compute to be 1.42 or 1.48 instead of the 1.62 shown above.
It all hinges on your overhead expense and how much profit you
want to make. We all have different expectations, desires, and
overhead expenses and therefore have different financial needs
and goal(s) for our companies. That is the main reason that I
tell remodeling contractors that one MARKUP, say 1.67, will not
work for everyone, or that a MARKUP of 10%, 15% or 21% may not
be right for everyone building new homes.
Still not convinced? OK, answer this question.
If, 90% to 96% of all contractors will not survive 10 years in
this business, and if you believe Dun & Bradstreet when they say
that most contractors go broke because of lack of profits
(i.e.…they don’t charge enough for what they do), then if you
try to be “competitive” by pricing your jobs at or close to what
you think “your competition” is charging for their work . .
.then what does that make your numbers?
Now keep in mind here that we are talking about
companies that do 2.5 million dollars in sales a year or less.
Most of the larger companies know their numbers well enough that
they seldom fall into the trap of trying to be competitive.
Plain and simple, they know better.
Every once in a while we hear some contractor
say that they will take a job for less than their markup
dictates because . . .”I must be competitive,” or . . “I have to
keep cash flowing through my company.” and of course there is
the famous . . .”I need to keep my guys working!” My answer to
each is the same, “No you don’t . . . what you have to do is
make a profit.” If you don’t, you and your company are going to
go away.
Then there is always the line about . . .”I’ll
make it up on the next one”. Right! Last but not least is the .
. .”The insurance company won’t let me charge more.” Right,
again! The bottom line is this; you have to make a profit or you
will not stay in business.
As we close this column, I hope you have given
some new thought on how to make your company a profitable
construction business. If you have, and have some questions,
please feel free to send them to us, and we will do our best to
answer them for you. Feel free to send them by e-mail to
michael@markupandprofit.com
Thank you for spending your time here. I am
always honored that a peer in our business of construction would
spend a few minutes of their time to read about new ideas and
review some old ones with me.
|